theplaneteater.gif (4047 bytes)

written by Norman Spinrad
STORY OUTLINE, dated March 6, 1967
report & analysis by
David Eversole

Ladies and gentlemen, I have almost nothing to say.

For something like seven years I have had the privilege of reviewing Star Trek's early draft scripts and story outlines for Orion Press, and have enjoyed cataloging all the changes a story goes through from its first broadly sketched strokes to the unveiling of the work on the canvas that is your television set. Some aired episodes bear almost no relation to the author's initial story treatment, some change very little.

This one changed less than little. It is that good, that concise! It says a lot when one of the three or so changes is the title change to the less-pulpy "The Doomsday Machine." And it was Spinrad's first stab at writing for the medium of film. Hard to believe. His story points are familiar to us, his characters make the same decisions. Well, Curt Decker does ram the shuttlecraft into the side of the planet eater, but it inspires Kirk to go down its maw with the Constellation.

The only noticeable change is that Spinrad posits that the "Eater" is a living entity. Not a machine in the least.

I've often heard that he was displeased with the final wind sock design, and had envisioned it covered entirely with wicked weaponry. This initial outline doesn't quite bear that complaint out.

From the description in the outline:

...a huge metallic creature...a kind of cylindrical "living atomic rocket" at least ten times the size of the Constellation, apparently from beyond the galaxy, with a posterior rocket and a great anterior funnel-mouth big enough to swallow a ship with a cluster of atomic blaster beams and tractor beams around the funnel, not a machine but a living organism with a nuclear metabolism.

Still, I can see how, over the years, the story might have been misremembered as "covered entirely" with weapons.

This has been Dave with little to say except, "Bravo, Norman!"

P. S. Oh, almost forgot, another change from outline to episode: Kirk relieves Decker of command and turns the ship back over to Spock through his authority as the Enterprise's "Captain-of-record."

Norman Spinrad (1940 - ): author, screenwriter and essayist known for such novels as Bug Jack Barron, The Iron Dream (an alternate universe Adolph Hitler eschews politics, emigrates to America anda becomes a pulp science fiction author), A World Between, The Void Captain's Tale, Child of Fortune, Little Heroes and Osama the Gun, to name just a few. His best short fiction is collected in The Last Hurrah of The Golden Horde. He wrote the feature film Druids, and for television, in addition to Star Trek, he penned episodes of Land of the Lost and Werewolf.

For Star Trek, he also wrote "He Walked Among Us," which was not produced. Likewise, he wrote an episode for the never-realized Star Trek: Phase 2, entitled "To Attain the All."

main.gif (11611 bytes)

Free counters provided by Vendio.

banner.gif (2815 bytes)

Click here to return to the Unseen Elements Page.
Click here to return to the Articles Page.
Click here to return to the Main Index Page.